Andrew Payne

Career Batting:.263 BA .311 OBP .328 SLG. 17 HR. 6,180 PA.(1902-1919)

Some projections have Andrew Payne (who went by the unfortunate nickname “Jap” in most sources) as a full time player for most of his career.

I just don’t see it.

I see Payne as a useful reserve OFer who had a predictable flow of performing well enough to earn additional playing time for a year or 2, then seeing his time reduced as his performance waned. This cycle happens twice in his career, with 1905 and 1906 being strong years and then 1910 through 1915. In the latter period, he could be a full time OFer on a bad team, or a key reserve on a good one.

He had a fair bit of power, especially for his time and I could see future revisions actually adding to his homerun output (which, by itself, might be enough to earn additional playing time, even if he struggled to hit above .220 for quite a few years).

He struck out a lot, and his walk rate was unremarkable.

Payne was solid in the OF with a mediocre arm. He had enough range to play CF, but was better suited for the corner OF spots, spending most of his career in RF.

We inserted a year in 1915, but other than that followed his historical record pretty closely.

NameAndrew Payne (Jap)
ID / Statuspayne049and / Draft
PosOF
DOB / i9s Career12/06/1879 / 1902 - 1919
BirthplaceWashington, DC (USA)
Height / Weight5'5" / 143
B / TR / R

 

Batting Projections

YearAgeABH2B3BHRBBSOSBCSBAOBPSLGOPS
19022284176103921.202.230.298.528
1903231202271041321.183.210.258.468
190424353742232114873.210.234.306.540
19052540412315532554216.304.345.389.734
19062649615014314370458.302.358.349.707
1907273568314201643134.233.266.284.550
1908282986712102144123.225.276.272.548
190929212461110174093.217.275.278.553
19103044812218422865447.272.315.344.659
19113154216920234183339.312.360.373.733
19123253013519224272289.255.309.309.618
19133340210315313961227.256.322.316.638
1914342999615312958184.321.381.401.782
1915353269213212851127.282.339.344.683
191636385909301954114.234.270.273.543
191737259771511173383.297.341.375.716
191838177381420133842.215.268.316.584
191939901840032221.200.226.244.470
TOTALS5,7811,522243391739985829382.263.311.328.639

 

Pitching Projections